|
The Plug-In Drug: Television, Computers and Family Life
 |
Author: Marie Winn
List Price: $14.00
Our Price: Click to see the latest and low price
ISBN: 0142001082
Publisher: Penguin USA (Paper) (30 April, 2002)
Edition: Paperback
Sales Rank: 35,404
Average Customer Rating: 3.78 out of 5
|
Customer ReviewsRating: 3 out of 5
Are Kids Addicted to the Tube?
Author Marie Winn has published several books about the medium of television and how it affects families and children. This book, "The Plug in Drug" was first published more than 25 years ago and has now been updated to include computers and other modern technology. Having been a television addict myself and someone who is interested in what others have to say about the ill effects of excessive TV viewing, I purchased thi book hoping to become enlightened about the destruction that can be caused by overconsumption of television. After reading this book, my feelings are mixed. The author (and the studies she sites from other's works) is decisively anti- television. She points out how families are not as closely- knit as they were in the past and how television viewing has caused kids to lose interest in other activities, like book reading and involvement in sports and outdoor recreation. She even draws the conclusion that the downward trend in SAT test scores can be atrributed to the rise of television viewing and popularity. Breaking the "spell" of television can be difficult. Parents find that TV viewing acts as a built- in babysitter and is also handy for use as a bribe. It's also much easier to let kids watch TV than to actively take part in other activities with them. This makes it especially tough to turn off the set and look for other, more productive ways to spend time. Winn doesn't call for the outlawing of television, and that's good because if she did, then I would immediately toss this book in the nearest sewer. Instead, she advocates watching television in moderation. She feels that, like anything, television can become addictive and that young children are the most vulnerable. Adults, too, can get hooked on TV but it's the children that are most susceptible to this "disease". Winn's opinions and her stance on television are sometimes accurate and sometimes a little over the edge. I can agree that, overall, most people watch too much television and that this can certainly take away valuable time that could be spent elsewhere. But I disagree on some of the more radical points, like the suggestion that kid's shows like Sesame Street are useless or that families should try going "cold turkey" and shutting down the set for good. I can only imagine the negative, rebellious response that would take place in most homes if a television- free environment was proposed by a parent. Overall, this is a decent book to read with a few good points to make about television viewing and keeping this activity in check. There is a good reference section in the back with names, addresses, and web sites of helpful organizations to turn to if you feel that yourself and/or your kids are television junkies. But much like Winn's suggestion that you moderate your TV consumption, you should also moderate how readily you accept her advice. Television has some good points, and there are some good, educational programs to watch. Complete elimination of television is not necessarily a good idea, in spite of what some psychologists and counselors have proposed. Moderation is the key to finding the right balance of television viewing vs. other activities for yourself and your family.
Rating: 5 out of 5
Should Be Required Reading
Marie Winn makes a compelling and convincing argument that TV addiction is drastically affecting our children's ability to learn. She is absolutely right. TV addiction is so overwhelmingly prevalent in this culture that living without TV is considered extreme deprivation. We can't so much as sit peacefully and quietly in a doctor or dentist's office waiting area -- the TV is everywhere. We Americans cannot function without it.Don't believe me? Unplug your TV and turn it around to face the wall. Don't touch it for thirty days. Thirty days of abstinence is the standard many psychiatrists use with patients who insist they aren't alcoholics. I got rid of my TV four years ago, and have suggested the thirty-day test to friends who insisted they weren't TV-holics. The longest anyone's ever made it is six days. People intuitively know that TV is wasting their precious life energy -- that's why every conversation starts off, "Oh, I hardly watch any TV at all...." which is bull, and we all know it. Marie Winn offers clear and cogent research and arguments to back up what we all, deep down, know to be true.
Rating: 1 out of 5
shocked at the lack of research
I eagerly dug into this book to learn more about the dangers of television but was utterly shocked at the poor level of research (especially given the glowing quotes from reviewers like The New York Times--goodness, doesn't anyone read footnotes?). Check out the footnotes and you'll see that speculations based on speculations is commonplace in this book. Research studies cited are often from 30 years ago but the author claims they're "just as valid today." Oh, really? They apply to interactive videogames, slow-cut educational videos with complex language such as Thomas the Tank Engine, etc.?
The part I was most interested in--information about the visual stimulation and how it might affect children with vision problems--was all based on a long out of print pamphlet that the author couldn't track down to verify. We're told that TV makes some kids hyper and some kids calmer...so it's bad for both groups...but why?
Moreover, recent research as reported in Time magazine shows that children do not watch TV like zombies as a rule--there is a lot of looking away from the television and engaging in other activities.
I'll keep searching for accurate, up to date information that will help me make sound decisions about my toddler's viewing of educational videos. Disappointed, to say the least.
|
