|
Great Web Architecture
 |
Author: Clay Andres, Serena Herr
List Price: $49.99
Our Price: Click to see the latest and low price
ISBN: 0764532464
Publisher: John Wiley & Sons (15 September, 1999)
Edition: Paperback
Sales Rank: 49,272
Average Customer Rating: 2.36 out of 5
|
Customer ReviewsRating: 1 out of 5
All Flash...Little Substance
This book contains lots of great pictures of web sites that have been completely re-designed since the writing of the book. Voila. If this is what you're looking for, then you'll be pleased with this book. However, if you're looking for more than that, look elsewhere. This book is a real disappiontment.It seems that many of the more "flashy" designs described by Andres have given way to more usable designs that actually make sense to real people using / desiging sites today. While that book states that author has web design experience - it doesn't seem like he shares much of that with us. For example, the author will generally state that a particular site uses flash or uses animated gif's but give's little detail about how animated gif's could be best used in site design and site architecture. The author spends most of his time criticizing sites and pointing out what he likes and doesn't like, which is fine. However, the author's tone is arrogant and self-absorbed. Additionally, the author ends chapters abrubptly, failing to guide the reader to the point that he might have been trying to make in that particular chapter. The only decent chapter in the book quite frankly is the chapter on hierarchical site organization (chapter one) and it's all downhill from there. This is one of the worst books I've ever read on the subject of web design.
Rating: 3 out of 5
The pictures can stimulate some creativity
Since any designer wants to keep on top of what's going on in the industry, I thought it good to take a look at this book. I've gone from cover to cover a few times, but not to read it. After beginning I quickly realized the information is pretty basic and can pretty much be found by speaking with other's in the industry.However, I did like some of the screenshots of various sites considered "great architecture." Often times, I flip through the book to generate a few ideas when putting together suggested views for sites in development. In all, not much new information, but may be worth it if you're just starting out and just need to know or need information reinforced.
Rating: 4 out of 5
Not about Architecture, but glad I got it anyways
I've been reading all the rants about this book, and I only kind of disagree. It's certainly not about "Architecture" of web sites, as the name would have you believe. I bought it for its intended (but mis-named) purpose: I wanted to learn about UI and navigational considerations. It's an excellent book for that. It discusses solutions to different types of web site goals and how the site designers approached these challenges. One particularly useful example was Andres' evaluation of the (pre-redesign) Salon.com site. Andres considers each navigational element on the site (the home page's article layout, the bar navigation along the top, the related article information on the sides, and the base navigation along the bottom) and explains the reasoning behind each choice. Another example that specifically helped me in the design of my own website was the Braun/Gilette example. Andres discussed the virtues of having each sub-brand be in a page-style all its own.Web UI books are difficult to write well, largely because the information is so timely and becomes outdated so quickly. The book has fantastic, full-color screenshots of each page in discussion so that, even if the page is no longer live on the web, it's still available for discussion. It's probably the most valuable UI book on my shelves (and there are a lot). People who didn't like it had purchased it under the false pretense that it was an Architecture book. Well, it's *absolutely* not that. It's a Web UI Design book, and a really good one.
Similar Products
· Homepage Usability: 50 Websites Deconstructed
|
